Lake Elmo Creamery | Your Hometown Ice Cream Shop 🍦
Our Flavor Menu
We rotate flavors weekly! While we have over 70 flavors in our lineup, we offer around 30 at a time. Check in to see what's currently scooping! We also offer to-go pints.
While we don’t make ice cream on-site, we’ve partnered with local premium suppliers to bring you both popular picks and fun rotating flavors.
Right now, enjoy scoops from Big Dipper Creamery, Cedar Crest, and more!
We offer celiac-friendly containers upon request, and many of our flavors are safe for those with gluten sensitivities. Flavor availability and quantities may vary.
Yes, we generally always have a flavor of dairy-free sorbet available.
At Lake Elmo Creamery, we offer a wide variety of flavors so there’s always something new and fun for everyone.
Below are some of our most-loved classics, but we like to keep things fresh and rotate flavors often — so not every flavor is available at all times. Stop by to see what’s currently scooping!
Classics
Chocolate Lovers
Classics
- Deluxe Vanilla – Smooth, classic vanilla ice cream
- French Vanilla – Creamy vanilla with an egg custard base
- Chocolate – Rich, creamy chocolate ice cream
- Strawberry – Strawberry ice cream with real fruit swirls
- Black Cherry – Black cherry ice cream with whole cherries
Fun
Chocolate Lovers
Classics
- Birthday Cake – Yellow cake ice cream with cake bits and sprinkles
- Superman – Swirled blue raspberry, cherry, and vanilla
- Cotton Candy – Cotton candy flavored ice cream with a swirl
- Bubble Gum – Pink bubble gum ice cream with gum pieces
- Blue Moon – Sweet, bright blue almond-flavored ice cream
- Playdough – Blue Moon ice cream with colorful cookie dough pieces
Chocolate Lovers
Chocolate Lovers
Indulgent & Loaded
- Big Muddy – Dark chocolate ice cream with brownie and caramel
- Elephant Tracks® – Chocolate ice cream with fudge and PB cups
- Chocolate Peanut Butter Swirl – Chocolate ice cream with peanut butter swirl
- Midnight Dark Chocolate – Deep, rich dark chocolate ice cream
- Pothole Mackinac Island Fudge – Dark chocolate ice cream with brownies and fudge
Indulgent & Loaded
Indulgent & Loaded
Indulgent & Loaded
- Pirates Bounty™ – Caramel ice cream, M&M’s and cookies
- Caramel Collision® - Caramel ice cream, caramel swirl & chocolate caramel mini cups
- Peanut Butter Cup – PB ice cream with PB cups and fudge
- Amaretto Mackinac Island Fudge – Amaretto ice cream with fudge pieces and swirl
- Mackinac Island Fudge – Vanilla ice cream with chewy fudge and butter fudge swirl
- Jumping Jersey Cow – PB ice cream with caramel cups and fudge swirls
- New York Cherry - Vanilla ice cream with maraschino cherry pieces
Dessert-Inspired
Indulgent & Loaded
Dessert-Inspired
- WI Campfire S’mores - Graham flavored ice cream with crushed peanut butter cups and a marshmallow swirl
- Blueberry Waffle Cone - Chocolate covered Waffle Cone pieces in Blueberry ice cream with a Blueberry Swirl
- Strawberry Cheesecake - Cheesecake flavored ice cream with a strawberry swirl
- Lemon Cheesecake - Lemon cheesecake ice cream with creamy cheesecake chunks and a graham cracker ribbon
Nutty & Crunchy
Indulgent & Loaded
Dessert-Inspired
- Butter Pecan – Roasted pecans in butter pecan ice cream
- Maple Nut – Maple ice cream with walnuts
- Praline Pecan – Vanilla ice cream with praline pecans and butterscotch
- Coconut Explosion - Coconut ice cream with chocolate-covered coconut pieces, flakes, and almonds
- Shipwreck – Vanilla ice cream with sea salt caramel and candied almonds
- Lady Bug® – Vanilla ice cream with chocolate, caramel, and pecans
Cookie-Inspired
Cookie-Inspired
Cookie-Inspired
- Cookies ’N Cream – Vanilla ice cream packed with crushed cookies
- Cookie Monster – Cookie dough and cookies in cookie dough ice cream
- Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough – Cookie dough and chips in cookie dough ice cream
Minty Fresh
Cookie-Inspired
Cookie-Inspired
- Mint Chocolate Chip – Green mint ice cream with chocolate chips
- Mint Mackinac Island Fudge – Mint ice cream with fudge pieces and swirl
Coffee Flavored
Cookie-Inspired
Coffee Flavored
- Daily Grind – Coffee ice cream with espresso beans and caramel
- Mississippi Mud – Mocha ice cream with cookies and fudge swirl
Sherbet
No Fat / No Sugar
Coffee Flavored
- Rainbow Sherbet – Lime, orange, and raspberry sherbet swirled
- Sunset Rainbow – Orange, raspberry, and pineapple swirled together
- Orange Twister - Orange sherbet swirled with vanilla ice cream
Sorbet
No Fat / No Sugar
No Fat / No Sugar
- Raspberry Sorbet – Bright raspberry flavored sorbet
- Raspberry Lemon Sorbet Twist – Raspberry and lemon sorbets swirled
No Fat / No Sugar
No Fat / No Sugar
No Fat / No Sugar
- Strawberry Swirl - No fat, no sugar vanilla flavored ice cream with a strawberry swirl
Lake Elmo Creamery
3549 Lake Elmo Avenue North, Lake Elmo, Minnesota 55042, United States
Copyright © 2026 Lake Elmo Creamery - All Rights Reserved.
This website uses cookies.
We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.